Updated 4 November 2026

Capsular Contracture: Symptoms, Baker Grades and Treatment Options

Capsular contracture is hardening and tightening of the scar-tissue capsule around a breast implant. It can cause firmness or hardening and, when severe, squeeze the implant, according to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Baker grades describe severity; ask a clinician to assess a change in your breast rather than assigning yourself a grade.

If you're considering a consultation, the breast revision in Thailand guide covers the wider revision topic. Start by asking what needs assessment and which options fit the findings.

Clinics cannot pay to be listed or ranked higher on AsiaPatient.

What capsular contracture is

The capsule is scar tissue around the implant. The FDA describes capsular contracture as hardening around the implant, with tightening that can be painful.

The cause is unknown, according to the same FDA guidance. It says contracture may be more common after infection, a hematoma (a collection of blood near the surgical site) or a seroma (a collection of fluid around the implant).

Changes the FDA and patient sources describe

Firmness or hardening appears in the FDA's definition. Its severe-grade descriptions also include a change in appearance, with pain included in Grade IV.

The UK National Health Service (NHS) breast implant guide describes the breast feeling hard because scar tissue has shrunk around the implant. Tell the clinician what has changed, when you noticed it and whether it is continuing to change.

What should be checked before deciding on treatment

The FDA advises discussing persistent swelling, pain or other changes around an implant with a clinician. It gives that advice in its discussion of evaluation for breast implant-associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA-ALCL), an implant-associated cancer.

A patient talking with a clinician across a consultation desk
Changes around an implant are worth discussing with a clinician. AI-generated illustration.

The FDA says a confirmed BIA-ALCL diagnosis may change the type of operation that should be performed. Ask what examination or investigations are appropriate before discussing a surgical plan.

Baker grades of capsular contracture

The FDA's Baker scale describes how the breast feels and looks.

GradeFDA descriptionSevere grade?
INormally soft and natural lookingFDA identifies III and IV as severe
IIA little firm but normal lookingFDA identifies III and IV as severe
IIIFirm and abnormal lookingYes
IVHard, painful and abnormal lookingYes

Use the table to understand a clinician's explanation. Ask which findings support the grade and how those findings affect your options.

The FDA says Grades III and IV may require another operation.

Capsular contracture treatment and revision terms

For severe Grade III or IV contracture, the FDA says reoperation may be needed. It usually involves implant removal, with or without replacement. The FDA also lists capsule removal and surgical release of scar tissue among possible reoperation procedures.

Ask the surgeon to name each part of the proposed operation. If several procedures are proposed together, ask why each is included.

Capsulotomy and closed capsulotomy

Capsulotomy means releasing the capsule surgically. The FDA lists surgical release of scar tissue around the implant as a reoperation option.

Closed capsulotomy involves manually squeezing the breast to break the hard capsule. The FDA doesn't recommend this for FDA-approved saline implants because it can cause rupture and deflation.

Capsulectomy

Capsulectomy means removing the capsule. The Breast Surgery Collaborative Community (BSCC) statement, hosted by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS), distinguishes complete removal from partial removal that leaves some capsule behind.

The BSCC statement lists capsular contracture as a possible reason for capsulectomy. Ask whether capsule removal is proposed in your case, how much would be removed and why.

Implant exchange or removal without replacement

The FDA's options include removing an implant and replacing it, or removing it without replacement. Ask the surgeon to explain both choices alongside any proposed capsule surgery.

Boyd's 2024 systematic review included 34 observational studies; population countries and a shared follow-up period aren't stated in its abstract. The authors say capsulectomy, implant exchange and changing the implant's placement appear useful for reducing recurrence, but more evidence is required.

Why en bloc isn't a synonym for capsulectomy

The BSCC terminology statement separates these terms:

The BSCC reserves en bloc for that cancer indication. The FDA removal page uses the term more broadly while discussing removal of some or all of the capsule.

Ask the surgeon to describe what tissue would be removed and the clinical reason, especially if the plan uses “en bloc.”

Risks and limits of revision surgery

The FDA says implant-only removal needs less surgical dissection (separation of tissue during surgery) and may carry less local bleeding risk. Removing part or all of the capsule may be a more extensive operation.

ASPS's implant-removal safety page lists risks including bleeding, infection, poor wound healing, fluid accumulation and scarring. It also lists the possibility of further revision surgery.

One 2022 study by Abi-Rafeh analyzed 2,231 surgeon-reported capsulectomies in the American College of Surgeons surgical quality database (United States) from 2015 to 2018. It covered several indications, including contracture and implant rupture.

Outcome in that database studyReported figure
Overall complications3.0%
Reoperation2.0%
Readmission2.0%
Hospitalization beyond one day after surgery6.32%

These are figures from one database study across capsulectomy indications. Ask how the proposed operation and your medical history affect the risks discussed at consent.

Recurrence is possible

Contracture can come back. The FDA says it could recur after surgery to correct it.

Ask how recurrence would be assessed and what the next discussion would involve if it happened again.

Factors sources associate with capsular contracture

The FDA says contracture may be more common following infection, hematoma or seroma.

Ask whether earlier complications are relevant to your assessment, without assuming they explain the change.

Radiation is a separate consideration in the 2026 Iliescu-Glaja narrative review. Its estimates concern reconstruction and radiation after mastectomy, so ask how that context relates to your operation.

What studies report about capsular contracture rates

The publications cover different populations, implants and follow-up periods. Keep each result with its study; don't average the figures or use them as your personal probability.

Study and populationFollow-up and countryFinding as reported
Zhu, 2021, one systematic literature review: 7,731 breast reconstruction and augmentation patients from six publicationsReports change over 10 years; population countries not stated in the abstractOverall risk increased from 7.6% to 25% in 10 years. Reported rates were 3% to 14% for textured implants and 6% to 20% for smooth implants. No significant difference between textured and smooth implants was observed when implants were placed under muscle.
Christodoulou, 2024, one systematic review and meta-analysis: 23 studies of implant-based breast reconstructionNo shared follow-up period or population countries stated in the abstractNo statistically significant difference for placement below versus above the chest muscle, or smooth versus textured surfaces. In the two studies that compared saline with silicone implants, saline implants had significantly lower contracture rates.
Iliescu-Glaja, 2026, one narrative review of implant-based reconstructionFive years for the non-irradiated figure; no separate interval given for the radiation figure. Population size and countries not stated in the abstractClinically significant contracture was approximately 3% to 5% at five years in patients without radiation, and 20% to 50% in those receiving radiation after mastectomy.
Maxwell, 2015, one prospective multicenter study of one silicone implant model (Natrelle 410): 941 subjects undergoing augmentation, augmentation revision, reconstruction or reconstruction revisionFollow-up through 10 years; country not stated in the abstractContracture rates increased approximately 1% per year from the previously reported six-year rates.

How to read these differences

The Zhu review reports different numerical ranges for smooth and textured implants, alongside its finding of no significant difference between textured and smooth implants when placed under muscle. The Christodoulou review reports no significant surface difference in its reconstruction analysis.

Ask which study applies to your original operation, implant and placement, and how long its patients were followed.

For someone who has had radiation after mastectomy, ask the surgeon to discuss that history separately. The Iliescu-Glaja review reports a higher range in that group.

What Thai hospitals and surgeons publish about revision

Yanhee Hospital's public list, read 4 November 2026, includes “Capsulectomy (previous Yanhee patient)” and “Capsulectomy - New Patient.” Ask which operation the hospital means for your assessment and whether implant removal or replacement is included.

Ekachai Hospital's plastic surgery list, read 4 November 2026, prints “Removal of Breast implant with Total Capsulectomy (2 sides).” That row lists general anesthesia and one admission night; ask how the proposed operation and admission plan would apply to you.

Dr Nond Rojvachiranonda's list, read 4 November 2026, separately names implant removal with capsulectomy, implant replacement and removal by “en bloc technique.” Ask the surgeon to explain the proposed technique using the tissue-removal definitions above.

What to ask a hospital to put in writing

Request the assessment and proposed operation in writing.

Recovery and flying to Thailand for revision

Ask for recovery instructions for the exact operation proposed, including the expected duration, any drains, support garment, wound care and stitch removal. Request separate advice about sleep, work, lifting and exercise.

Before arranging travel, ask how long to remain near the hospital, which reviews need to happen in person and when the surgeon would assess fitness to fly. Ask who to contact if recovery changes the departure plan.

In this section: breast revision surgery in Thailand and breast implant replacement.

Frequently asked questions

What are the first signs of capsular contracture?

The FDA describes firmness or hardening; its severe grades include changed appearance and, for Grade IV, pain. Ask a clinician to assess a new change rather than using those descriptions to diagnose it yourself.

What are the Baker grades?

The FDA scale runs from I, soft and natural looking, through II, a little firm, to III, firm with abnormal appearance, and IV, hard and painful with abnormal appearance. The table above gives each description; FDA calls III and IV severe.

How is capsular contracture treated?

The FDA says severe cases may need reoperation, usually implant removal with or without replacement. Its reoperation options include capsule removal and surgical release of scar tissue.

Can capsular contracture be treated without surgery?

The FDA says it hasn't cleared or approved any device to treat or reduce the incidence of capsular contracture.

Ask whether observation or any nonsurgical treatment is appropriate for your assessment, and what evidence supports the proposed approach.

Can capsular contracture come back after revision?

Yes. The FDA says capsular contracture could occur again after corrective surgery.

Is en bloc capsulectomy the same as total capsulectomy?

No. Under the BSCC definitions, total capsulectomy removes the whole capsule; en bloc also removes a margin of uninvolved tissue for suspected or established implant-associated cancer after appropriate assessment.

Ask a Thai Surgeon Which Grade You Have and What They Would Do, in Writing

Tell us the procedure, your budget and your dates, and any hospitals you are considering.

Get My Free Quote →

Free, no obligation. Nothing goes to a clinic without your OK.